This scorecard is a point of view, and we say so. It measures officials against a set of stated positions we call California First. If you don’t share those positions, you will not agree with the grades. What we promise is that the yardstick is written down, the same for everyone, and that every grade shows the actions and the sources behind it.
These are the positions every official is measured against, whatever their party.
Jobs and trade. For California workers and California-made goods in state contracts; against rules that push employers and jobs out of state.
Taxes. Against new or higher state taxes and fees.
Fraud, waste and abuse. For audits, clawbacks and penalties.
Bloat. For cutting agencies, headcount and overhead; against new boards and commissions.
Crime. For tougher penalties for theft, drug and violent crime; against early-release laws.
Judicial processes. How judges are picked, their track record, the attorney general and district attorneys, and severe sentencing for violent cases.
Infrastructure. For building roads, water storage and power on time and on budget.
Immigration. For state cooperation with federal enforcement; against sanctuary-type laws; state benefits for citizens and legal residents first.
Foreign influence. For limits on foreign ownership of farmland, ports and utilities, foreign money in ballot measures, and pension investments in foreign adversaries.
Healthcare. Citizenship or legal residency first for state-paid coverage; lower costs and fewer mandates; against a single state-run plan.
LGBT. For telling parents, keeping girls’ sports and spaces by sex, and limiting gender treatment for minors.
DEI. Against DEI offices, mandates and race-based preferences in state government and schools.
Socialist-style bills. Against government takeovers of industries, rent control and similar measures.
Innovation and technology. For keeping tech in California; for safety rules on the most dangerous AI risks; against rules that drive tech out without a safety purpose.
Elections. For voter ID and clean voter rolls, while keeping voting easy for eligible citizens.
Cost of living. For lower insurance costs and more companies writing policies in California; against rules that drive insurers out.
We list an official’s actions on these issues. Each action is marked Aligned if it matches the position above or Not aligned if it goes against it. The grade is the share that are aligned: A 95% or more, B 90%, C 85%, D 75%, F below 75%. An official needs at least 10 counted actions to get a letter.
What counts as an action. A dated decision the official made with the power of the office: a vote, a signature or veto, a lawsuit, a rule, an order, an audit, or a bill the office officially sponsored. Speeches, campaign promises and endorsements do not count. Neither do routine duties where the official had no choice.
Which record each office is graded on. State lawmakers and the Governor: their votes, signatures and vetoes on our bill list. Members of Congress: grades from the America First Foundation. The Attorney General and other statewide officials: lawsuits, rules, orders, audits and recorded board votes. County and city officials: their recorded votes and official policies. Winners of the November 2026 election who have not taken office yet are graded on the office they held before.
All eight statewide offices are held by Democrats, so every statewide grade on this site belongs to a Democrat. Republicans are graded on the State lawmakers, Congress, Counties and Cities tabs against the same positions and the same cutoffs.
Some actions can fairly be argued either way. We don’t hide those. The site’s owner ruled on each one, and each ruling is shown here so you can judge it yourself. So far 80 statewide actions were close calls; 18 were ruled aligned and 62 not aligned.
Standing rules. When the same kind of action comes up again, it is scored the same way.
| Kind of action | Ruling |
|---|---|
| Refusing to give the full voter list to federal investigators, or not acting on a federal list of likely non-citizens | Not aligned |
| Objecting to federal election monitors, barring voter removals based on mass outside challenges, stopping a county hand count | Not aligned |
| One-year bans on insurers dropping home policies in wildfire areas | Aligned |
| Approving a sharp insurance rate increase, or a large charge on insurers to fund the last-resort FAIR Plan | Not aligned |
| Awards of affordable housing tax credits and bonds (subsidized housing) | Not aligned |
| Backing the sale of pension-fund oil and gas investments | Not aligned |
| Lawsuits against large tech companies over competition or content, and defending the state net neutrality law (a lawsuit over unsafe testing of dangerous AI was ruled aligned) | Not aligned |
| Fighting federal tariffs in court or by official letter | Not aligned |
| Blocking or protesting oil and gas projects, or state deals to push offshore wind | Not aligned |
| State designations or programs based on race | Not aligned |
| Lawsuits and guidance that work against federal immigration enforcement | Not aligned |
| Sponsoring new state mandates on employers or new state benefit programs | Not aligned |
| City mandates and giveaways: free city college, stricter eviction rules, higher required affordable-housing shares, a city minimum wage | Not aligned |
| Routine duties where the official has no choice (certifying results, qualifying a measure that met the count) | Left out |
Every close call, by official. Tap a name to see that official’s whole record.
Not aligned Won a court ruling letting California's net neutrality law SB 822 take effect while the suit continues Source
Not aligned Joined a multistate suit saying Facebook bought Instagram and WhatsApp to wipe out rivals Source
Not aligned Urged the California Supreme Court to end unaffordable bail, so that people are not held before trial only because they cannot pay Source
Aligned Sued Purdue Pharma over opioid sales and marketing Source
Not aligned Sued the Trump administration over a citizenship question on the 2020 Census Source
Not aligned Joined 20 states and D.C. in suing the FCC over repeal of net neutrality rules Source
Aligned Sued OpenAI, saying it built and tested advanced AI models it knew were dangerous without the safeguards needed to protect the public, after dozens of cyber incidents Source
Not aligned Took Meta to trial over claims that Instagram and Facebook harm children and collect data from under-13s Source
Aligned Led 24 states in suing over a federal rule on Medicaid work requirements for medically frail people Source
Not aligned With the Governor, sued to stop the President from putting California National Guard troops under federal control Source
Not aligned With the Governor, sued the Trump administration over tariffs imposed under an emergency-powers law Source
Not aligned Issued two guides telling immigrants their legal rights and warning about immigration scams Source
Not aligned Sued Amazon over contracts that stop sellers from offering lower prices elsewhere Source
Not aligned Chaired the first meeting of the new state Governing Board for Black-Serving Institutions, which designated 31 colleges and universities for their record with Black students Source
Aligned Voted yes at the State Lands Commission (2-0) to change the lease for the water pipes of the Ormond Beach power plant, adding a $1.5 million payment from GenOn for monitoring Source
Not aligned As State Lands Commissioner, signed a partnership with the Ports of Long Beach and Humboldt to upgrade the ports for floating offshore wind turbines Source
Not aligned As acting governor while Newsom was away, signed a bill extending eviction protections for some renters to the end of June Source
Not aligned Set up a Transgender Advisory Council in her office; in 2023 the council issued a statement against school district votes to tell parents when a child changes gender identity Source
Aligned Held a public hearing on blockchain and digital assets and said California needs clear rules that protect consumers Source
Not aligned Opened applications for California HOPE accounts: $3,000 trust accounts for foster youth and children who lost a caregiver to COVID-19 Source
Not aligned Invested $150 million of state pooled money in a 5-year Inter-American Development Bank bond for Latin America and the Caribbean Source
Not aligned Sponsored AB 2123, the Medical Debt Relief Act of 2026, a state program to buy and cancel medical debt for eligible Californians Source
Not aligned Signed, with the Controller and 13 other state finance officers, a letter asking President Trump to follow the Supreme Court tariff ruling and to repay those hurt by the tariffs Source
Not aligned Backed the CalSavers rule, now in full effect: employers with one or more workers and no retirement plan must offer a plan or sign up for CalSavers; penalties for not complying Source
Not aligned The two committees she chairs approved the final 2025 housing awards (254 projects, 28,850 units for the year); California was first to adopt a 25% bond test after a July 2025 federal law change, using emergency rules Source
Not aligned Sponsored SB 769, the Golden State Infrastructure Fund Act, a new financing body inside the Treasurer's office to pay for infrastructure with bonds repaid from project revenue, not state debt, and to favor projects that keep or add jobs Source
Not aligned The two committees she chairs approved about $1.9 billion in housing tax credits for 66 projects (CTCAC) and about $2.17 billion in tax-exempt bonds (CDLAC) Source
Not aligned Publicly backed SB 252 (CalPERS and CalSTRS stop new fossil fuel investments and sell existing ones by 2030) after the CalPERS board voted to take a position on it Source
Not aligned CalPERS board voted to oppose SB 252 (stop new fossil fuel investments and sell existing ones). Ma's designee, Frank Ruffino, voted No, which is against opposing the bill Source
Not aligned Her office sponsored SB 1126, signed by Governor Newsom, which extends the CalSavers requirement to employers with one or more workers, phased in with a Dec 31, 2025 deadline for those with fewer than five Source
Not aligned CalPERS board voted to oppose SB 1173, a fossil fuel divestment bill. Ma's seat voted No (against opposing), cast by her designee Source
Aligned CalSTRS board voted to oppose SB 1173, a fossil fuel divestment bill. Ma's designee, Frank Ruffino, voted Aye (for opposing), per the minutes Source
Not aligned CalPERS board approved the CEO's 2020-21 incentive award and 2021-22 base salary. Ma's seat voted Aye through acting member Frank Ruffino; one member voted No Source
Aligned The committee she chairs (CTCAC) approved a plan to give $100 million in federal fire recovery tax credits to 13 wildfire-hit counties Source
Not aligned As a CalSTRS board member, broke with the Investment Committee and backed students and teachers who want CalSTRS to sell about $6 billion in fossil fuel holdings Source
Not aligned The tax credit committee she chairs (CTCAC) approved about $52.5 million in federal and $53.3 million in state credits for four affordable housing projects, and she began a 10-city tour on changing the selection rules Source
Not aligned After DOJ demanded on Oct 13 that the state review a list of people it said were likely noncitizens and act within 48 hours, she answered that DOJ never gave her office the list, that the 48-hour deadline caused chaos, and that state law already requires citizenship and removal of ineligible registrants. Source
Not aligned After the California Supreme Court ruled the Riverside County Sheriff's months-long seizure of over 1,000 boxes of election materials unlawful, said her office would work with the county registrar and sheriff to return the materials in an orderly and secure way. Source
Not aligned Wrote to the U.S. Homeland Security Secretary refusing to share the voter list, saying her office had not given it to any federal agency, and asking DHS to explain how it found 190,000 alleged noncitizen voters by Aug 3. She said no mass cancellations would be made within 90 days of the election. Source
Not aligned Filed her answer in court to the Judicial Watch lawsuit (filed May 20, 2026) that says she did not make a reasonable effort to remove voters who moved or died from the rolls. Source
Not aligned After DOJ sued her on Sep 25, 2025 for the full unredacted voter list, filed a motion to dismiss. The federal court dismissed the case on Jan 15, 2026; DOJ has appealed. Source
Not aligned Said DOJ gave her office no reason for sending federal election monitors to five California counties for the Nov 2025 special election, and that her office would take every step to protect voters from interference. Source
Not aligned Told counties that mass third-party challenges to voter registrations are not authorized by statute, that no list-maintenance removals based on them are allowed in the 90 days before a federal election, and that counties should not match on name and birth date alone. Source
Not aligned Told the U.S. Justice Department that California would only let it look at a redacted voter list in person in Sacramento, and would not send an electronic list with driver's license or Social Security numbers. Source
Not aligned Sponsored AB 1249: counties outside the Voter's Choice Act must offer an early voting site on the Saturday before statewide elections, and voters may hand in mail ballots in person without the ID envelope (still checked as usual). Source
Aligned Answered the Lieutenant Governor's request to remove Donald Trump from the 2024 primary ballot under the 14th Amendment by saying any decision must follow state law and the Constitution; he stayed on the ballot Source
Not aligned Her office ruled that Assemblymember Vince Fong could not run for the 20th Congressional District in March 2024 because he had already filed to run for re-election to the Assembly. A court overruled her on Dec 28 and she put him on the ballot but said she would appeal Source
Not aligned Wrote to the Shasta County supervisors that a plan to hand count the Nov 2023 election broke the new state law (AB 969) and her office would act to make the county follow it. Source
Not aligned After an independent readiness check found the Cal-ACCESS replacement was not ready, decided to restart planning and said it would not launch in 2022. Earlier, on Jun 11, 2021 she postponed the June 30, 2021 launch. By Nov 2022 she had cancelled the prior vendor contracts and moved oversight to state staff. Source
Not aligned Adopted emergency rules (later proposed as permanent) for same-day conditional voter registration: a person can register and vote a provisional ballot in the 14 days before and on Election Day. The ballot is counted only after checks for prior voting, signature and ID data. Source
Not aligned Said the 2026-27 state budget she must administer had changes meant to steady revenue, including broadening the tax base, and warned that without them California could face deep program cuts. Source
Aligned As Franchise Tax Board chair, directed the board's staff to return with an analysis of why fewer eligible people claim the CalEITC, Foster Youth and Young Child tax credits, and a plan to raise take-up. Source
Aligned Mailed notices to about 130,000 Californians who may be owed unclaimed property, matched against Franchise Tax Board records, after a Dec 2025 round of 100,000 letters that returned $30.4 million. She said the funds belong to Californians, not the state. Source
Aligned Released the state's annual financial report for the year ending June 2025 with a clean audit opinion, the first in eight years issued before the Governor's May budget update. Reports say it still came about 42 days past the usual nine-month deadline. Source
Not aligned As chair of the State Lands Commission, called an emergency session and voted yes, 2-0, to authorize litigation to defend the 2020 consent decree and challenge Sable Offshore's federal order to restart offshore oil transport. Source
Aligned Praised the Governor's veto of SB 414, which would have created a new Education Office of Inspector General to do forensic audits of charter schools, saying her office already has that audit power. She said she would work with lawmakers on stronger charter oversight. Source
Not aligned Proposed rules to stop insurers from using a driver's marital status when setting auto insurance rates Source
Aligned Ordered a one-year ban on cancelling or not renewing home policies for more than 64,000 policyholders near the Gann Fire, and for the first time covered some commercial properties such as HOAs and apartments Source
Not aligned New rule took effect that sets clearer rules for intervenors in rate reviews, gives the public more hearing information, and may require paid intervenors to disclose funding sources and conflicts of interest Source
Not aligned Department settled with State Farm and Consumer Watchdog on the earlier emergency rate request: home increase stays 17%, rental dwelling set at 32.8%, condo about 5.8%, with refunds plus 10% interest Source
Aligned Ordered a one-year ban on cancelling or not renewing home policies for more than 147,000 policyholders near fires in Kern, Santa Barbara, San Luis Obispo and Ventura counties Source
Not aligned Announced plans to change how outside groups (intervenors) take part in Prop 103 rate reviews: clearer pay rules, public reports, and time limits for judges Source
Aligned Filed an Order to Show Cause against the California FAIR Plan for denying and limiting smoke damage claims after the Palisades and Eaton fires Source
Aligned Finished review of the first forward-looking wildfire catastrophe model (Verisk) and approved a temporary FAIR Plan expansion to up to $100 million of coverage per high-value commercial property, ending in 2028 Source
Not aligned Adopted a judge's ruling that let State Farm raise home rates 17% on an emergency basis if its parent company put in $400 million, and barred new block non-renewals through 2025 Source
Not aligned Approved a $1 billion assessment on insurers to keep the FAIR Plan paying fire claims, and ordered the FAIR Plan to hire staff and use its reserves and reinsurance Source
Aligned Ordered a one-year ban on insurers cancelling or not renewing home policies in ZIP codes tied to the Palisades and Eaton fires Source
Not aligned Issued the Net Cost of Reinsurance in Ratemaking rule: caps reinsurance costs insurers can pass on to customers, limits them to California, and requires the same catastrophe model for reinsurance and rates Source
Aligned Began enforcing a rule that makes insurers give discounts for wildfire safety work on homes, file rates that reflect it, and share home wildfire risk scores Source
Not aligned Introduced and voted for a $9 million appropriation to fund Free City College, passed 9-1 over the Mayor's objection Source
Not aligned Introduced the resolution to make City College of San Francisco free to residents and city workers; Board passed it 10-1 Source
Not aligned Pushed to raise the affordable housing requirement on new developments from 12% to 25%, and won 40% in two major projects in her district (listed on her Board page; date not shown) Source
Not aligned Co-sponsored the deal with Supervisor Breed to table an $80 million state grant for a new county jail; the Board rejected the Mayor's jail plan 11-0 Source
Not aligned Authored and passed a tenant protection ordinance meant to stop frivolous evictions (listed on her Board page; date not shown) Source
Not aligned Passed a law raising the city's minimum wage to $15 an hour by 2018 (listed on her Board page; date not shown) Source
Not aligned Backed the Fair Chance Act, which removes barriers to jobs and housing for people with conviction records (listed on her Board page; date not shown) Source
Not aligned Sponsored and backed bills that were signed, including Medi-Cal billing for school-based health services and vision care for low-income children Source
Not aligned Sponsored AB 1078, which bars book bans and censorship of instructional materials and lets the Superintendent buy textbooks for districts that refuse to provide them Source
Not aligned Sponsored AB 101 (ethnic studies as a high school graduation requirement) and announced ethnic studies teacher training and a task force on inclusive education Source
Not aligned As board president, board voted unanimously to move a developer plan for 1,500 below-market homes for district educators on its University Heights headquarters site into negotiation Source
Every action links to its source. Check it. If an action is wrong or missing, the record should be fixed, whichever way it moves the grade.